Katharine Hepburn Fenwick Estate Off The Market

by Categorized: Katharine Hepburn House Date:

Katharine Hepburn’s storied home on the Connecticut shore is no longer for sale.

Owner Frank J. Sciame told me late Wednesday that he pulled the estate off the market a week ago after two years and no offers that matched the $30 million asking price.

“I’m not going to sell it for less than the asking price,” Sciame said.

Katharine Hepburn's former home in the borough of Fenwick. Courant File Photo/Richard Messina

Katharine Hepburn’s former home in the borough of Fenwick. Courant File Photo/Richard Messina

Sciame said he and his wife, Barbara, plan to use the house in the exclusive, Old Saybrook enclave of Fenwick as a summer home — as they did before putting it up for sale. They also plan to begin construction of a second, smaller house on the property this fall

“We are going to build a guest house in September, right after Labor Day,” Sciame said.

Sciame disclosed that the house was no longer on the market in an interview with Property Line about his winning a $2.2 million jury award against the company that provided title insurance for the former Hepburn property.

Click here for more photos of the Hepburn Estate

Sciame, a Manhattan-based developer, and his wife, Barbara, purchased the 3.5-acre Hepburn estate for $6 million in 2004, a year after the actress’s death.

They completed a top-to-bottom, multimillion dollar renovation, which included raising the entire house 5-1/2 feet to guard against flooding. The Sciames also secured approval to subdivide the property into three lots, planning for future construction.

Sciame said the complaint against First American involves the title insurers failure to determine that what the Sciames thought was a private driveway actually was a “discontinued road” still owned by the Borough of Fenwick.

The Sciames had purchased $6 million title insurance policy when they purchased the property with a clause that increased coverage to $9 million at the time of the recent trial in Superior Court in Hartford.

First American, Sciame said, first offered to pay Sciame $17,000 in 2007 to compensate for the error, but Sciame balked. In June, the jury awarded $2.2 million and earlier this month, a Superior Court judge in Hartford denied motions by First American to set aside or reduce the award.

Sciame has since worked out an easement with the borough.

“The $2.2 million judgment is a victory for all of us who hold property insurance,” Sciame said. “It sends an unmistakable message that an insurer cannot make a title error on a policyholder’s property and avoid compensating the insured; that it must meet its policy contract obligations in good faith and in full.”

A view to the main house from the lot where a guest house is planned. Photo by Richard Messina/The Hartford Courant

A view to the main house from the lot where a guest house is planned. Photo by Richard Messina/The Hartford Courant

A call to First American’s office in Hartford for comment was not immediately returned today.

This is not the only controversy involving the storied seaside estate where Hepburn spent her retirement years. Sciame also battled with the borough over the height of granite marker posts marking the entrance of the driveway.

Construction on the guesthouse cannot begin until after Labor Day because Fenwick zoning regulations do not permit building in the summer.

The plans call for a 2,750-square foot guest house with three bedrooms that will be built to the east of the 8,500-square-foot main house.

When asked about whether he would sell if a buyer offered the full price now that the house was off the market, Sciame said: “No, not at the moment.”

The $30 million asking price reflected plans for the construction of the guest house. A structure on the third lot also is possible.

The Sciames originally had planned to sell the renovated estate as soon as the work was done, but they kept it as a summer house for several years because it became a family favorite.

“Katharine Hepburn wasn’t wrong when she referred to it as paradise.” Sciame said.

The Courant is using Facebook comments on stories. To comment on courant.com articles, sign into Facebook and enter your comment in the field below. Comments will appear in your Facebook News Feed unless you choose otherwise. To report spam or abuse, click the X next to the comment. For guidelines on commenting, click here.

7 thoughts on “Katharine Hepburn Fenwick Estate Off The Market

  1. walls

    A house is only worth what somebody is willing to pay for it. I guess it’s not worth 30 mil.

  2. winesour

    It’s a beautiful location and the house is spectacular inside. If I had $30 million, I’d buy it. The Sciames did a beautiful job preserving and improving this property, I’m glad they are going to continue owning it.

  3. Johnny 2 Dogs

    wow. he won a suit against a title insurance company? Holy cow. These things are owned by lawyers and they’re never willing to part with “their” money. If you see this guy buying lotto tickets, play the same numbers.

  4. Robin

    Rumors that the Obama’s were going to purchase it several years ago. Their daughters spend part of their summers in the area. Betcha that’s why it’s off the market.

  5. commercial real estate

    You really make it appear really easy along with your presentation but I in finding
    this matter to be really something which I believe I would by no means understand.
    It sort of feels too complex and extremely extensive for me.
    I am taking a look forward on your next publish, I will try to get
    the hold of it!

  6. Elizabeth Mulholland

    I grew up in Fenwick and was in Kate’s house many times as a guest. The “discontinued road” was public. It had a Borough sign on it and was named “Mohegan Drive”. It went down to the Sound and Kate didn’t like people going by her house and onto “her” (though it was public) beach. So on Oct. 2, 1962, she had the sign pulled up and the world believed the road was hers.
    There is other info on Kate in my book, “Surviving High Society” which can be bought on Amazon or Kindle.
    Elizabeth Marvin Mulholland

    1. Susan Braden

      We had done a story on the house when it was first put on the market for $28 mill…did not know that the beach was public property…town or borough? that would upset some folks in the borough…would love to hear from you…sbraden@ctcentral.com and learn more about your book as well.

Comments are closed.